A car is not a horse

https://stephenfry.substack.com/p/ai-a-means-to-an-end-or-a-means-to

A transcript of a very good speech that Stephen Fry gave recently. It’s about AI (or Ai as he prefers to call it …) and the very serious problem of understanding the future we face in its presence.

He reminds us that a car is not a horse, that a plane is not a bird, that technology does not imitate. By the same reasoning, AI is neither a brain nor is it intelligent. AI does not imitate.

Let’s get over it.

The next time I read that AI endows computers with the ability to do things that an intelligent human can do I will rip up the book, article or delete the podcast.

A car is not a horse and does not do horse things. AI is not intelligent and does not do intelligent things.

History is about the future…

For reasons I won’t go into I just read this paper:

Readman, P. (2005). The Place of the Past in English Culture c. 1890-1914. In Past & Present: Vol. Feb. (Issue 186, pp. 147–199). Published by : Oxford University Press on behalf of The Past and Present Society. http://www.jstor.com/stable/3600854

It discusses the role of history in creating an understanding of the past as a way to understand our present, and then from that we gain an understanding of what we should become present and an idea about what we want to become, i.e. history is about the future as much as, if not more than, the past.

The Mechanical Mind … again

Reading Audrey Watters’ 2nd Breakfast post today, stimulated a comment I wanted to make: https://2ndbreakfast.audreywatters.com/agents-versus-agency/.

But I am undergoing a major cancellation of subscriptions (I found I have been spending over £300 per year on various things over and above my internet subs and hardware maintenance). This has to stop! So, while offering comments on posts like Audrey’s is in part evidence of how good and therefore stimulating they are … BUT it’s too often a paid-for feature. A barrier to dialogue.

Continue reading “The Mechanical Mind … again”